Square footage: what counts?
When my clients are listing their homes or looking for new ones, the square footage/size of the house is one of the essential facts to provide. Sounds pretty straightforward, right? Well, sometimes it’s not. The first is understanding what counts as square footage. While I’ve been asked about garages, no, that square footage should never be included. Technically, even unfinished basements may be considered as part of the total square footage. The problem is that, at least in Pennsylvania, the tax records are inconsistent in how they record square footage. Sometimes unfinished basements will be included in the total, and sometimes they won’t.
Finished vs unfinished square footage
How to compare
Then comes the question of whether finished basement space counts “the same”. What I mean is that many buyers ask whether total finished square footage is the best criterion to use to compare different houses. While it’s better than considering unfinished space as equivalent to finished space (meaning it has sheetrock and heat, flooring and a finished ceiling and lighting, etc.), there is still a difference in finished space that is in the basement vs. above ground. Above ground square footage is a field in our local MLS that agents are meant to fill out. The most “apples to apples” comparison is above grade square footage. In a basement, the space is not usually as desirable, especially if it is not a walk out. Basements can be dark, with low ceilings and are rarely as nice as above ground spaces. Furthermore, they are separated from the other main living space.
Why the location of the space matters
The other reason why it’s so important to understand whether a property listing’s square footage includes or excludes the basement has to do with the size of the other floors and the rooms on those floors. This example should illustrate my point:
Listing #1 says a house is 2500 sq ft with 4 bedrooms.
Listing #2 says a house is 2250 sq ft with 4 bedooms.
When you read the fine print, you see that the square footage in listing #1 includes the finished basement, which is about 500 sq. ft. That means that the main two floors is each roughly 1,000 sq. ft. The size and shapes of the rooms on each of those floors is constrained by that total of 1,000 sq. ft. and bedrooms will be small.
Listing #2 does not have a finished basement, so the 2250 sq. ft. amount constitutes only the two main floors. That means the footprint of each is roughly 1125. With 125 sq. ft. more per floor, the rooms in listing #2 will be appreciably more spacious (or could allow for a laundry room, larger closets, or other ancillary space). Please note: finished basements do have value! It’s not that they don’t “count”. They just don’t count on a psf basis the same way above ground does.
Who’s counting?
As I mentioned before, Pennsylvania’s tax records are not consistent in how the different square footages (total, total finished, total above grade finished) are recorded, but there is another factor: human error. It’s not uncommon for sellers to report inflated square footage amounts when they have built additions or finished previously unfinished spaces. Additionally, some agents who don’t read those already unclear tax records correctly, they sometimes add the finished basement space to the TOTAL finished square footage (not the above grade finished square footage). I don’t believe this is done to purposely mislead; I think it happens when an agent is not being careful. Either way, the result is that the total reported square footage is overstated. It’s a good idea to ask you agent to pull the tax record just so you can see the entries and decide what is the most accurate amount and how the space is carved up.
The takeaway
Remember that every buyer has a different set of needs and preferences.One buyer might prefer listing #1 above, if that finished basement would be perfect for an office or playroom or overflow space for their guests. Another buyer might prefer fewer, larger spaces. So it’s not a matter of better; it’s simply a matter of different. The important lesson here is to just understand what information you’re being given so you can make an informed decision about what space configurations work best for you.
If you are relocating to the Philadelphia/Main Line area, please go to my blog page and search for posts using the relocation tag. Contact me to discuss your Philadelphia area relocation! jen@jenniferlebow.com/610 308-5973