What should I look for?
Some home buyers look for a “starter” home–one that will be in the budget today, but that they expect to outgrow (or otherwise want to move up from) fairly soon. On average, people stay in those houses around six years before looking to move. Other house hunters are looking for a “forever”, or at least very long-term, home. If you wonder how you would make that decision, consider the pros and cons of each type of house.
Starter Home
Starter homes tend to be smaller, more modest and often less appealing as far as location, lot size, school district, amenities and sometimes condition than forever homes. By definition, most people who identify their search as one for a starter home don’t expect to stay in it long-term. Why might someone look for a home they don’t plan to stay in?
Advantages
- Starter homes are typically more affordable. Buyers who can’t yet afford what they might consider a forever home can still own a house if they purchase a starter home.
- With a lower mortgage, the buyers’ financial risk is reduced, in case unexpected expenses arise. This fact is especially important for younger people who sometimes don’t figure in all of the maintenance and other (often hidden) expenses of home ownership.
- Another financial advantage is the ability to build equity–with a manageable payment, people who purchase starter homes can build equity (by paying the mortgage down and because real estate tends to increase in value over time) which converts to cash upon the sale of the house. This money can be used to help them purchase the next house, or for anything else they need it for.
- Starter homes, since they have a lower mortgage, allow for greater flexibility in the event the owners want to move or have a job change. They are also usually easily saleable as there are always first-time home buyers who are looking for starter homes.
- Starter homes can be a great teaching tool–they can help buyers determine what actually does and does not matter in a home and property. Sometimes, things people think are really vital end up not being all that important, like a garage, for example. Similarly, there may be things, like a finished basement, that might not have seemed important, but now becomes a must-have.
Disadvantages
- Starter homes are usually small. If your family grows, or you need work-from-home space or an area for hobbies or other specialized activities, you may feel cramped.
- Moving is expensive. Not only are closing costs (here in Pennsylvania) high, but you have moving trucks, time off of work and other costs.
- Moving is disruptive. No one likes moving and if you have kids in schools that will change with a move, you need to consider whether that change is major or minor.
- You may see lower appreciation in a starter home if it’s in a less desirable area or has certain features (like very limited closet space, for example) that are hard to overcome/change.
- If you’ve put money into updating the property, the return on your investment may be financially negative if you don’t stay in the house long.
- Creating community can be hard if you feel like you won’t be staying in the neighborhood. If you are hoping to establish roots and deep relationships with neighbors and people who use the same gym/day care, etc., recognize that those friendships may be hard to maintain if you don’t live nearby.
.
Long-Term Home
Many people are looking for something they plan to stay in for many years. Often, though not always, these are people who have owned a home previously and have reached a life stage where they have a clearer picture of the future–income expectancy, family size, where they ultimately want to be, etc. Here are some of the pros and cons of purchasing what is expected to be a long-term home.
Advantages
- More space is often the most obvious difference between starter and long-term homes. Extra room is a luxury which can be used for storage, a growing family, hosting guests, and potentially even housing an aging parent. That extra interior space is often mirrored outside–more room for a dog or kids who want to play oustide.
- It’s usually less of a financial risk to make updates and improvements to a house you expect to stay in. You can worry less about resale value, since the expectation is that you will live in the house for a long time and benefit from the improvements. For the same reason, you can customize them to your specific needs and taste with less worry about how someone else will like them when you sell the house, since that probably will be many years away.
- Houses in more desirable neighborhoods (which is normally where people look for long-term homes) tend to appreciate more, so investing in these properties is usually a wiser financial move.
- Remaining in a neighborhood for a long time increases the likelihood of making lasting connections in the community, vs. moving after a few years.
Disadvantages
- Long-term homes are usually more expensive, requiring a larger down payment, higher closing costs and more substantial mortgage payments.
- With a larger mortgage, and more cash/savings being spent on the purchase, the financial risk is greater in the event of a change in financial status.
- Due to the financial constraints of a more expensive home, you will have less flexibility if your circumstances change as far as selling/moving.
- Larger homes often require more maintenance and upkeep, particularly in an area where most of the housing stock is older. So keeping the trees trimmed, the driveway sealed, replacing windows, updating HVAC systems, replacing roofs, remodeling bathrooms–all of these projects are expensive.
- Sometimes, the things that are important to buyers in a property/community change over time, and if you determine the neighborhood is not what you expected or no longer suits you, you have a lot more invested financially than if you’d purchased a more modest home. So it’s important, if looking for a “forever” home, that you feel confident it will be a good fit for many years, not just for now.
Obviously, there is no right or wrong answer as far as whether you should look for a starter vs. a longer-term home. It depends on your current and (future expected) financial situation, how clear you are on what kind of home and neighborhood you will want not just now, but 15+ years from now, how predictable or unpredictable your future is (how likely job changes are, whether it’s probable you might want to move to be closer to family members, etc.) and other lifestyle factors. Consider your priorities and how each option aligns with your goals.